Record 22 of 126
Record:   Prev Next
Author Cartwright, Steven Richard
Title mans commentaries of William of St. Thierry and Peter Abelard: A theological and methodological comparison
book jacket
Descript 305 p
Note Source: Dissertation Abstracts International, Volume: 62-06, Section: A, page: 2209
Adviser: E. Rozanne Elder
Thesis (Ph.D.)--Western Michigan University, 2001
In 1140, William of St. Thierry, a Cistercian monk and former Benedictine abbot, accused Peter Abelard, the well-known philosopher and theologian, of propagating grave errors concerning Christian doctrine in his theological teachings. William's accusations resulted in Peter's condemnation at the Council of Sens in 1140
This study compares the commentaries on the Epistle of St. Paul to the Romans written by William of St. Thierry and Peter Abelard in the mid-1130s, only a few years before William's accusations. While this conflict has been much studied, no one has previously examined it via these commentaries, which are the only literary genre William and Peter had in common, and which deal directly with many of the Christian doctrines disputed by the two scholars. The study examines their exegetical methods, specifically their citations of Scripture and the Fathers of the Christian church, and their use of spiritual exposition, rhetoric, and dialectic. It also analyzes their statements on key doctrines, including grace, original sin, and the Trinity. It points out both their significant methodological and doctrinal differences and similarities, and shows how their differences may have contributed to their conflict. Tine study proposes that the conflict can be understood as an argument between a monk committed to the Augustinian program of rhetorical exposition outlined in <italic>De doctrina Christiana</italic> and a scholar committed to the dialectical methodology of Boethius
School code: 0257
Host Item Dissertation Abstracts International 62-06A
Subject History, Medieval
Religion, Biblical Studies
Alt Author Western Michigan University
Record 22 of 126
Record:   Prev Next